Kay lives here

working with the web

iStock_000004617544XSmall

Web Directions South 07: iPhone blah blah

iStock_000001670492Small

I’m cur­rently at the Web Direc­tions South con­fer­ence in Syd­ney, get­ting myself a dose of inspi­ra­tion to last for the next 12 months. We’re about to embark on the sec­ond day, so here’s some thoughts from the first.

There’s a real buzz around social net­works and the mobile web — in John Allsopp’s open­ing com­ments he said the the mobile web had “arrived” and I really think he’s right. However, I’m get­ting sick of the iPhone love-in. Yes, they’re shiny, yes they have a full browser, yes, every Apple fan­boi must have at least two. Blah blah blah. Brian Fling’s after­noon ses­sion, enti­tled “Web 2.0 + Mobile 2.0 = ?” started off great, with an overview of the  cur­rent state of mobile usage world­wide and the poten­tial — which is huge.  How­ever, the sec­ond half of the pre­sen­ta­tion was iPhone mania.

I realise that the pur­pose of the ses­sion was to look for­ward to what is likely to hap­pen in the mobile space, but I can’t help feel­ing that there’s a dis­con­nect — on one hand talk­ing about the mas­sive poten­tial of the mobile web and the stag­ger­ing num­ber of internet-enabled phones “in the wild”, but on the other, cre­at­ing iPhone-only web appli­ca­tions that don’t degrade to other devices and are there­fore only acces­si­ble to the per­cent­age of the US mar­ket that already has one. Aus­tralia is more on par with Europe and Asia in terms of mobile phone own­er­ship and usage — we’ve been using SMS for a lot longer, for exam­ple, and 3G is where things are at. So even when the iPhone does make it over, the lack of 3G will prob­a­bly restrict its mar­ket see­ing as the internet-enabled early adopters are mostly using Hutchison’s 3G net­work (3 has the best pric­ing by far).

In 2005 there were nine mil­lion mobile phones in Aus­tralia, and a pro­por­tion of them are already inter­net enabled — this is the mar­ket that I want to build mobile web sites for now. I want my mobile sites to be acces­si­ble to every­one with a net-enabled phone. So I won’t be build­ing any iPhone-only sites.

Tech­no­rati Tags:

5 Comments

  1. Kay,

    Thanks for attend­ing my talk. An hour seemed very tight for try­ing to unpack both the con­cepts of Web 2.0 and Mobile 2.0.

    I know there are a lot of peo­ple that dis­agree with design­ing specif­i­cally for the iPhone, but I stand by this assertion.

    The prac­ti­cal­i­ties of design­ing and devel­op­ing for the mas­sive num­ber of mobile devices out there is very dif­fi­cult and very costly. The iPhone is the best device and being able to deliver web stan­dards to mobile sub­scribers, mean­ing the time and cost of mobile devel­op­ment is dra­mat­i­cally reduced.

    Fur­ther­more the state of the mobile web user expe­ri­ence is so poor that the addi­tion of good stan­dards sup­port allows design­ers and devel­op­ers to cre­ate qual­ity and valu­able user expe­ri­ences, that con­sumers expect from the web, over the mobile web, some­thing that has never really been done before.

    As I men­tioned in the talk, all the signs of the mobile indus­try are point­ing towards the iPhone being the new bar in mobile browser tech­nol­ogy… basi­cally mean­ing good ren­der­ing of standards.

    And like I pointed out, Apple is really the first com­pany out­side of the oper­a­tor world to really attempt to shift the per­cep­tions of con­sumers of what mobile tech­nol­ogy can do. This will greatly increase the demand for mobile web con­tent and services.

    This means that it isn’t about design­ing specif­i­cally for the iPhone, it means design­ing with *Stan­dards*, again some­thing that is fairly unique to the iPhone now, but I promise you not for long.

    Thanks again for attend­ing,
    Brian

  2. Okay I don’t have an Iphone. I have played with them.

    Its a nice wifi browser, thats it, its pretty, thats it. Its an apple, thats it. Its not really a phone, unless you have a wifi network.

    I just have to point out that the Apple Iphone is at present a minor player, a minor crip­pled phone with old tech­nol­ogy. The iPhone has been made for the func­tion­al­ity of the US net­work. It’s not really tar­geted for out­side of the US net­works in the rest of the advanced ITC sec­tor that its for the main ahead of the US (yes Aus­tralia is ahead of it) .

    The space we need to really watch is iPhone V2 or the response from other phone vendors.

    Maybe we need to tem­per our view a lit­tle beyond all the apple glitz and glamour.

    Per­son­ally I sick of the phone. Sim­i­larly with the itouch.

  3. Brian: seri­ously, the iphone does not, and will not ever mat­ter to any­one but a select group of smug Apple fan­bois. You can not say “there are gonna be 6 bil­lion mobile subs by _____” and think any­one of those peo­ple will have iphones. Ever.

    What a snore fest.

  4. Hi Rob, I heard about your pre­sen­ta­tion and I was *really* sorry I did miss it — it sounded great. I will check out the slides and the pod­cast when it comes out.

    Brian, my only other com­ment about your pre­sen­ta­tion — which I did hon­estly think was very good, I’m a huge fan of http://dev.mobi, it’s just that I am annoyed at the iPhone hype — was that right at the end you men­tioned that the iPhone would be the first of a whole new gen­er­a­tion of phones, and I am cer­tainly look­ing for­ward to a cou­ple of years down the track when they start to fil­ter out to the wider world.

  5. Hi Kay,

    sorry you didn’t get a chance to see our Mobile Web presentation…sounds like it was more what you were look­ing for.

    We pre­sented a real time inter­ac­tive poll that also dynam­i­cally graphed the types of phones/browsers that the peo­ple in the room were using and what Net­work Provider they used.

    We then also asked a range of ques­tions about Mobile Device and mcom­merce usage patterns.

    You can see the begin­nings of the data analy­sis dis­cus­sion at our blog http://MobileOnlineBusiness.com.au/blog or you can view the screen grabs of the pre­sen­ta­tion on slideshare — http://www.slideshare.net/robman/e-is-for-everywhere-interactive-mobile-web-presentation/ .

    roB­man